Episode 7: Midlife Crisis or Midlife Breakthrough? Why Millennials Are Experiencing This Shift Earlier
Are you between 30-45 and finding yourself asking, "Is this it?" You're not alone. What previous generations experienced as a midlife crisis at 50-60 is now happening to millennials much earlier. But what if this uncomfortable transition isn't a crisis at all, but rather your greatest invitation to growth?
In our latest episode of The Pursuit of Happy Well podcast, we explore why the concept of "midlife crisis" needs reframing and how understanding this natural life transition can transform restlessness into revelation.
Why Millennials Are Having Their "Midlife Crisis" Earlier
The data is clear: millennials are experiencing their "midlife crisis" between 30-45, much earlier than the traditional 50-60 window. But why?
Several factors may contribute to this acceleration:
Multiple economic disruptions (millennials have faced as many as four "once in a lifetime" recessions)
The disillusionment with traditional success metrics after achieving them
Social media's constant comparison culture
The realization that the "American Dream" hasn't delivered as promised
As we discussed in the episode, there's a sense of being "bamboozled." You checked all the boxes – career, house, family, stability – but something still feels hollow. The question that dominates Reddit forums for people 40+ is simply: "Is this it?"
Beyond Sports Cars: What This Transition Really Means
The Hollywood version of midlife crisis – buying a Ferrari, making dramatic career changes, moving across the world – captures only the external manifestations of what's actually a profound internal shift.
Carl Jung described this as moving from the first half of life to the second. Each half has distinct purposes:
First Half of Life: Building the External
The first half focuses on:
Establishing your identity and ego
Building career and reputation
Creating family and fulfilling social roles
Accumulating experiences and achievements
Meeting external expectations
This phase is essential – we need to develop a strong sense of self before we can transcend it.
Second Half of Life: Developing the Internal
The second half shifts toward:
Depth over speed
Presence over productivity
Meaning over metrics
Legacy and contribution
Internal values rather than external validation
As Jung supposedly said (though it's often attributed to him without clear sourcing), "Life doesn't begin until 40; everything before that is just research."
The Container Metaphor: Richard Rohr's Perspective
Richard Rohr, in his book "Falling Upward," offers a helpful metaphor for understanding this transition. He describes the first half of life as "building the container" – creating the structure and scaffolding that will hold the meaning of your life.
The second half is about filling that container with meaning, depth, and spiritual growth.
The challenge comes when:
You cling to first-half activities even as your soul is ready for second-half growth
You try to fill the container before it's properly built
You mistake the container itself for the purpose of life
As we discussed in the podcast, "What worked in life's morning doesn't work in the afternoon of life."
When Your Soul Outgrows Your Ego: The Tension That Creates "Crisis"
The uncomfortable feelings associated with midlife transition often stem from a mismatch: your soul is ready to move into the second half of life while your ego clings desperately to first-half metrics and achievements.
This tension creates the restlessness that might make you want to:
Change careers abruptly
Move somewhere completely new
End relationships
Make dramatic lifestyle changes
These impulses aren't wrong – sometimes significant external changes are needed. However, making these changes without understanding the deeper transition happening can lead to what we call "changing the scenery without changing the view."
From Crisis to Breakthrough: Reframing the Transition
The word "crisis" implies something has gone terribly wrong. But what if nothing has gone wrong at all? What if this uncomfortable transition is exactly what should be happening?
Reframing "midlife crisis" as "midlife breakthrough" acknowledges that:
The discomfort is purposeful - It's pushing you toward necessary growth
The questioning is valuable - It's helping you align with what truly matters
The shift is natural - It's part of human psychological development
As Kristen says in the episode, "Midlife is not about you going crazy. It's about you waking up to yourself and being like, this is what actually matters."
Three Shifts in the Second Half of Life
In our podcast, we identified three fundamental shifts that characterize the move from first to second half:
1. Depth Over Speed
The first half of life rewards speed, productivity, and constant motion. The second half invites slowing down enough to go deeper.
Kristen shared a powerful story about a retreat she attended where she initially felt frustrated by being asked to simply sit and take in the view. Her mind was racing with "we've got work to do!" But after sitting in silence, she found herself crying – the uncomfortable emotions that surface when we finally slow down.
Her guide's response? "That is the work."
2. Presence Over Productivity
Our culture celebrates productivity above all else. The second half of life invites us to value presence – being fully engaged with what's in front of us rather than constantly doing.
This shift explains why many people in their 40s start declining social invitations that would have excited them in their 20s. As the comedian Nate Bargatze jokes:
In your 20s: "Where are we going? Let's go!"
In your 30s: "What time does it start? I'll drive separate."
In your 40s: "I'm not going anywhere. From the couch to my bed at 9 PM."
3. Meaning Over Metrics
Perhaps most importantly, the second half of life invites us to pursue what's meaningful rather than what's measurable.
This doesn't mean abandoning metrics entirely – it means ensuring they're aligned with your deeper values rather than external expectations.
Navigating the Transition: Two Powerful Questions
If you're experiencing this shift, two questions can help you navigate it with intention:
1. What part of you is trying to retire, but you keep resurrecting?
This question invites you to examine where you might be clinging to old identities, roles, or success metrics that no longer serve your deeper development.
Many of us experience physical or emotional symptoms – anxiety, restlessness, even panic attacks – when we repeatedly force ourselves to maintain identities our souls have outgrown.
2. What is life asking you to release so something truer or more meaningful can rise?
This question helps you identify what needs to be let go to make space for new growth. Sometimes letting go feels like death – but it's actually making room for rebirth.
Examples of Midlife Transitions in Different Contexts
This pattern of transition shows up in many contexts:
Professional Athletes
Consider Tom Brady's initial retirement struggle. When your identity is built entirely around being a football player, who are you when that role ends?
Empty Nesters
When your primary role has been caregiver and coordinator for your children, what defines you when they leave home?
Career Transitions
If you've built your identity around being the best in your field, how do you handle a career change or retirement?
This is why Scott noted that retirement is particularly challenging for men who have defined themselves primarily through their professional roles and achievements.
Why This Isn't Just Another Self-Help Topic
Understanding the two halves of life isn't about applying another productivity hack or self-improvement technique. It's about recognizing a fundamental shift in human development.
This understanding can:
Prevent unnecessary suffering - Knowing this transition is normal reduces the panic
Guide better decisions - You can respond intentionally rather than reactively
Deepen your life satisfaction - Aligning with your soul's deeper longings creates fulfillment
As Jung suggested, many people never fully enter their second half of life. They continue building and expanding their container without filling it with deeper meaning.
Conclusion: Embracing the Breakthrough
If you're experiencing what feels like a midlife crisis – questioning your path, feeling restless in roles that once fit perfectly, or wondering "is this it?" – consider that you might actually be experiencing a breakthrough.
This transition, though uncomfortable, is an invitation to a more authentic and meaningful life. By understanding the natural shift from first half to second half, you can approach this period not with fear but with curiosity and intention.
As we emphasized in our podcast: This isn't about abandoning everything you've built. It's about honoring the container you've created while filling it with what truly matters to you now.
Are you navigating your own midlife transition? Share this article with someone who might be experiencing similar questions or join our free Facebook community, The Pursuit of Happy Well, to continue the conversation.
Listen to the full episode of The Pursuit of Happy Well podcast wherever you get your podcasts for more insights on navigating this important life transition.
Join the Movement
Ready to redefine what success and happiness look like for you?
Subscribe on Apple Podcasts
Follow on Spotify
Watch full episodes on YouTube
Join the conversation on Instagram
Share with friends who are also questioning the standard success narrative
Remember, you're not just here to exist—you're here to thrive. Keep going, keep growing, and join us next time on The Pursuit of Happywell.
About Your Hosts
Scott and Kristen built a $20+ million business before realizing that traditional success metrics weren't telling the whole story. They've coached thousands through both business and life transformations, learning firsthand that the path to fulfillment isn't what social media portrays. Based in Colorado with their two kids and two dogs, they bring authentic conversations about what actually creates a well-lived life in today's complex world.
Follow us on social! Kristen’s Instagram | Scott’s Instagram
Join our growing Podcast Community NOW 2.5K and climbing
